2025 Cadillac XT4 vs. BMW X1

Stylish, bold and ready to comfortably take you where you need to go, the Cadillac XT4 is a jewel in the Cadillac model lineup. The XT4 was brand new for the 2024 model year, and continues its momentum going into 2025. However, is the Cadillac XT4 as good as advertised? Follow along with our team as we compare the 2025 Cadillac XT4 against a fierce competitor in the 2025 BMW X1.

Performance Battle

The 2025 XT4 comes out of the gate ready to deliver with its turbocharged 2.0 L, 4-cylinder engine, offering 235 hp and 258 lb-ft of torque. Every XT4 model will be mated to a 9-speed automatic transmission. Other highlights of the XT4’s performance include drive mode selector, available twin-clutch AWD, and active fuel management. 

Looking at the BMW X1, we find a similar turbocharged I4 to the XT4, as the X1 offers 241 horsepower and 295 lb-ft of torque, paired to a 7-speed automatic transmission. The 2025 X1 also offers similar performance features in the form of BMW’s xDrive, all-wheel drive system,  and BMW’s MyModes, the equivalent of Cadillac’s drive mode selector. After the performance battle, these vehicles are dead even.

Interior & Exterior Design

Design is a strong suit for the 2025 XT4, as the luxury SUV most recently received a refresh for the 2024 model year. The XT4’s front fascia is commanding, flanked by slim vertical LED headlights with standard Intellibeam technology. Stepping inside the cabin is stepping into true Cadillac luxury as high-quality materials are abundant. Other design highlights include available 20” alloy wheels, available sunroof, best-in-class rear legroom (1003 mm), and 1,385 L of total cargo volume.

In comparison, the BMW X1 had a recent refresh back in 2023. The design is modern, complete with sleek LED lighting that you’d expect from BMW. However, the front fascia design is controversial with many enthusiasts showing displeasure from the current modern generation BMW grille. Otherwise, expect to find high-quality materials in the cabin of the X1, standard 18” wheels, and 1,550 L of cargo volume. After the design battle, the slight edge goes to the XT4.

Technology & Safety

Cadillac’s technology and safety are renowned for good reason, these categories shine with the 2025 XT4. Drivers can expect more than 20 standard and advanced safety features. Some of the highlighted technologies on the 2025 Cadillac XT4 include:

• Enhanced Automatic Emergency Braking
• Intersection Automatic Emergency Braking
• Rear Cross Traffic Braking
• Front Pedestrian and Bicyclist Braking
• Reverse Automatic Braking
• Adaptive Cruise Control
• Enhanced Lane Keep Assist with Lane Departure Warning
• Traffic Sign Recognition
• Blind Zone Steering Assist

Exploring the safety and technology that the BMW X1, the standard suite of technology and driver assistance features offered is noticeably smaller than that offered on the XT4, highlights include.

• Automated Emergency Braking with Pedestrian Detection 
• Lane-departure Warning and Blind-Spot Monitoring 
• Rear Cross Traffic Alert
• Front and Rear Park Distance Control
• Driving Assistant

XT4 vs. X1 Verdict

With performance being neck and neck, an edge in the design category given to the XT4, the 2025 Cadillac XT4 pulls ahead by a mile thanks to its comprehensive suite of standard technology and safety features offered, making the XT4 the winner of this tough fought battle.

A perfect harmony of utility, luxury and style, the 2025 Cadillac XT4 is the top choice for a luxury SUV in Ontario. Shop the 2025 Cadillac XT4 right here in Goderich at McGee Motors Cadillac. To learn even more about the Cadillac model lineup, check out our new Cadillac models, and browse used vehicles from all makes and models. Don’t forget to schedule service, shop parts, and more. Contact McGee Cadillac in Goderich today, and book your test drive.